Showing posts with label wrestling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wrestling. Show all posts

22 January 2015

A Few Thoughts on the Product

The Road to WrestleMania is already in full swing. In the course of the WWE bus getting on that road, they felt the need to undo everything that was accomplished at Survivor Series. At Survivor Series, John Cena's team defeated the Authority, with Dolph Ziggler eliminating the final three members of Team Authority, with a little help from Sting.


As a result of the victory, the Authority was stripped of power and removed from television. Thanks to Vince McMahon, John Cena was given the power to bring the Authority back or to keep them out of power. Just a month later, Seth Rollins knocked out Christian and, with the help of the Big Show, held the injured Edge's neck over the Money in the Bank briefcase and threatened to cripple the Rated-R Superstar if John Cena did not bring back the Authority. Cena gave in, and then all of Dolph Ziggler's hard work was rendered meaningless.

On the next episode of Monday Night Raw, the Authority held a John Cena Appreciation Night, during which they fired Ryback, Erick Rowan, and Dolph Ziggler, leaving a dejected Cena standing in the ring with the fired superstars. So now, with the Royal Rumble fast approaching, the over-arching storyline in January 2015 is the same that it was in January 2014, except that Batista isn't here.

Frankly, the truth is that the product stinks. So I put some thought into some different ideas about fantasy booking

The Royal Rumble's Final Four

One of the biggest things about the Royal Rumble is to pay attention to the final four wrestlers left in the match. This is, more often than not, an indication of who WWE plans to push in the coming year. Given the storylines the company has been pushing lately, the final four for this year’s event may seem obvious.

Roman Reigns has been anointed by the WWE as the next big thing in wrestling. Problem is, his promo work is sub-par. He can work with almost anyone, although he’s still learning the babyface style, which in WWE means getting his butt handed to him for 90% of the match before executing a comeback of epic proportions and winning. John Cena is a master of this. Cena can, seemingly, be beaten within an inch of his life and then come back and win. Go ahead and chalk Reigns up as a final four participant.

The next man up, obviously, is Daniel Bryan. Bryan’s return from injury has been a feel-good story so far. Having him reach the final level of the Rumble would whip the fans into a frenzy.

So we have two babyfaces in the final four…who’s next? To get the requisite heel into the final four, we turn to Bray Wyatt. The Eater of Worlds has been on a steady rise since the summer. He’s scored victories, albeit dirty, over Dean Ambrose and Daniel Bryan in the last month. Wyatt would be a great choice for the final four, and it would set him up for a major heel push headed into WrestleMania season.

The final member of the Final Four is a fan favorite: Dolph Ziggler. The Show-off is probably the best ‘seller’ in the company, and can make anyone look good in the ring. Reaching the final four would set Ziggler up for a steady rise in 2015, leading to a big match at WrestleMania.

The End of the Rumble

Last year’s Royal Rumble was a debacle of near-biblical proportions for the WWE. The intention for Batista to win the Rumble was made clear from the day Batista returned to the company. Once Daniel Bryan did not enter the Rumble, the fans turned on the then-babyface Animal. Batista was left in the ring with Roman Reigns, whose Shield stable was still in their heel role at the time. The fans turned on Batista and began cheering for Reigns, a basically unproven rookie, to win the Rumble over the despised part-timer.

This year’s Rumble will be different. WWE has several options, but the apparent design at the moment is for Reigns to win the Rumble and face the WWE World Heavyweight Champion at WrestleMania 31.

But there’s another option that sets up almost every main event level storyline for the WrestleMania season. It’s a bit of fantasy booking on my part, but here’s a thought:

The final two wrestlers in the Royal Rumble are Daniel Bryan and Roman Reigns. All other 28 wrestlers have been eliminated. Being competitors and babyfaces, the two men shake hands before engaging in what amounts to a one-on-one match to end the battle royal. That is, until the clock starts counting down, the number 31 appears on the screen and the Big Show comes out. Reigns and Bryan begin working together to eliminate Big Show. But the clock starts again and out comes Jamie Noble at #32, followed immediately by Joey Mercury at #33. Reigns and Bryan manage to eliminate Mercury and Noble, but keep struggling with Big Show.

The clock starts again and Seth Rollins comes out at #34. Rollins and Big Show work together, but Big Show is accidentally eliminated. Rollins begins to back away from Reigns and Bryan, leading to a bit of babyface vengeance as they beat down Rollins and eliminate him. Before they can restart their one-on-one, the clock starts one last time and, at #35, out comes Triple H. While Reigns and Bryan stare at the COO, Big Show, Rollins, and J & J Security sneak back in and attack them.

Big Show, Noble, and Mercury hold down Reigns in the corner while Rollins and Triple H decimate Daniel Bryan. Ryan suffers a Pedigree and, while he is struggling up, is curb-stomped by Rollins. Triple H picks Bryan up by the hair and throws him at the feet of Roman Reigns. He takes a mic and tells Reigns to throw Bryan over the top rope. Reigns at first refuses, but Triple H threatens to fire him if he doesn’t. Reigns reluctantly picks up Bryan and carries him to the ropes. He dumps Bryan over the top, but follows after him, simultaneously eliminating them both, and ruining Triple H’s plan.

Triple H, being the Cerebral Assassin, declares himself the winner of the Royal Rumble. It’s massive heat for the Authority. It sets up Reigns’s opposition to the Authority and Rollins in particular. It sets up for finally bringing closure to the Bryan-Authority angle.
Reigns can defeat Triple H at Fast Lane to regain the WrestleMania title shot. We can set up the inevitable Triple H vs Sting match that is sure to happen. Daniel Bryan will enter a feud with Seth Rollins.

Triple Threat Title Match

The WWE World Heavyweight Championship match was set to be John Cena challenging mostly-absentee champion Brock Lesnar. But, in one of the better heel moves in the industry, Triple H rewarded his protege, Seth Rollins, a spot in the title match for coercing John Cena into re-instating the Authority.

Lesnar, while being around only occasionally, has been quite effective as champion. Any appearance by Lesnar has enhanced whatever Raw it occurred on. Cena, while not the best choice for #1 Contender, is definitely the safest choice. WWE knows that Cena can carry a title program, so it trusts him against Lesnar. Rollins, meanwhile, has been on a steady climb up the ladder since destroying the Shield and aligning himself with Triple H. Rollins currently holds the Money in the Bank Briefcase, guaranteeing himself a title shot. 

The problem now, though, is what happens to Brock Lesnar? There's talk that Lesnar is almost done with the WWE. So now rumors are flying that the company is going to book Lesnar to lose the belt at Royal Rumble. I don't think so.

Lesnar needs to be champion at WrestleMania 31, so that the Rumble Winner gets the rub of beating the man who conquered the streak at WrestleMania 30. Whether it is Reigns or Bryan, defeating Lesnar will be huge...and it will set up the WrestleMania twist.

I would have Lesnar defeat Rollins, just so that Cena doesn't take yet another loss to Lesnar. Lesnar can finally gain revenge on Rollins and carry the title into WrestleMania. 

At WrestleMania 31, Lesnar will defend the title against either Bryan or Reigns. Lesnar will lose. It's inevitable. When Lesnar loses, he will snap and demolish the new champion, leaving them laying in a head in the middle of the ring in the middle of Levi's Stadium. As the new champion is struggling to his feet, Seth Rollins will cash in the MITB contract, curb stomp the champion, and claim the title. It will put massive heat on Rollins, and it will establish the WWE World Heavyweight Championship angle for the summer months.

02 December 2014

The Sad Dawning of a New Day

On the July 21 episode of Monday Night Raw, Kofi Kingston and Big E took on Ryback and Curtis Axel. RybAxel won the match fairly decisively. As Kingston and Big E stood in the ring talking to each other about the loss, Xavier Woods made his way to the ring. Woods grabbed a mic and delivered the following promo:

“Everybody listen! I need you to pay attention to what I’m about to say. This is exactly what I have been talking about. You cannot move ahead by shaking hands, kissing babies, singing and dancing, like a puppet. You cannot move ahead by always doing what you’re told. Now…this is our time. This is our place. It is time for us to find focus. It is up to us to find order. Together it is our time to find purpose. Because we do not ask any longer…now, we take.”

Kingston began nodding in approval almost immediately, and Big E got on board as Woods finished speaking. The trio began working together, and the next night on Main Event, Kingston and Big E crushed Heath Slater and Titus O’Neil. But, this being WWE, since the group didn’t have 100% fan support after one match, they were shoved to the back burner. They continued working together at house shows, but on Raw and Smackdown they were clearly not working on the same team, although their ring attire always seemed to match.

What the Woods Factions could have been...
Then, a few weeks ago, WWE began airing pre-taped vignettes featuring Xavier Woods dancing in front of a gospel choir. The tag line at the end said a “New Day was coming.” A week later Kofi Kingston got in on the act. Another week went by and Big E started appearing in these videos. A New Day, it appeared, was upon us. And good grief has it been a disappointment.

Xavier Woods promo about it being their time to focus and take, which bore all the hallmarks of a turn into heel or tweener territory, was basically scrubbed from history. Instead, WWE resorted to the worn out trope of casting three black men as southern African-American evangelists. There was a design, it seems, that was set to cast the Woods Faction as angry, almost militant, black men tired of being held back by their gimmicks. But after the continual uproar and fallout from Ferguson, Missouri, it appears WWE decided to scrap that plan for fear of offending anyone.

So a new gimmick was rapidly drawn up and thrown on them. They debuted on Smackdown, which WWE doesn’t even care about anymore. Their first match on Raw was ruined almost from the start. As the trio appeared on stage, Jerry “The King” Lawler was quick to announce “Hey look, they’re happy.” Right, God forbid an angry black man not named Mark Henry exist in the WWE. The faction was beaten fairly quickly in a tag team turmoil match, but their defeat paved the way for a feud with Goldust and Stardust.

What WWE Creative turned the Woods Faction into...
I had high hopes for the Woods Faction, but for now it appears as though WWE has set them up to fail.

And of course New Day is going to fail. WWE is so afraid of pushing the envelope by having legitimately angry black men in a group that they reverted to the tried and true, happy-go-lucky African-American southern evangelist trope for the entire group. How they went from Xavier Woods's "now we take" promo to this is sad, but not a mystery.

WWE could've easily capitalized on the group by turning them tweener/heel, but apparently the toddler fan base they are catering to would not accept a heelish Kofi Kingston, so Creative instead took Kofi's happy-in-the-face-of-all-injustice personality and slapped it on Woods and Big E as well. It wouldn’t have been a difficult booking effort, either.

At Survivor Series, a Fatal-4-Way tag team match was contested for the Tag Team Championships. Near the ending point of that match, having the Woods Faction interfere would’ve been the perfect introduction. They could beat down every team in the ring and then, as Woods said in his promo, “take” the Tag Team titles and leave. Over the following weeks they could defend the tag titles with both clean victories and dirty victories. Once their claim to the titles was legitimized, all kinds of feuds would be available. Feuding with the Dust Bros would be just as easy as feuding with the Usos.

You would have a true tweener group. An intense tweener group would've done wonders for the tag team scene and the midcard. Instead, true to the 4-year-old demographic they are targeting, WWE is casting all wrestlers in good or evil mode. There are no tweeners anymore. There are no anti-heroes. That would've been a great slot for the Woods Faction. Instead, we get super-babyface, so-happy-it's-sickening, Kofi, Big E, and Xavier Woods, doing exactly what Xavier Woods said had held them down in the past. So either Woods is far more stupid than his documented education would lead us to believe, or Creative is so afraid of offending someone that they reached into the bag of stereotypes instead of creating something new. It's disgusting how badly Creative has already screwed the pooch on this one.

26 September 2014

State of the WWE, Post-Night of Champions

We’ve now had time to digest what happened to the WWE at Night of Champions, and we’ve seen the fallout from the pay-per-view event. Let’s examine a few issues going on at the moment… 

The United States Championship Feud 

Sheamus is still champion. In one of the best matches of the evening, he and Cesaro basically stole the show. I figured Sheamus would win, and he did. But the trouble is his character remains staler than month-old bread. Cesaro is rapidly approaching the same stage of his career. WWE seems adamant in not wanting to change either man’s character or alignment, yet they’re just watching both men tumble down the roster. If Sheamus is going to remain a babyface then he needs to enter a program with Rusev for the US Title. If he’s going heel, then I can think of several wrestlers he could feud with to get him there, including one who might be able to pull off the double turn. 


Cesaro, back when he was US Champ
Cesaro, meanwhile, now moves on from chasing Sheamus. I’ve yet to determine why WWE is dragging their feet with Cesaro. He has all the talent in the world and he has a move set perfectly suited to a babyface. Yet the stubbornly keep him heel. When he began to get too popular, around the time of WrestleMania, WWE latched him on to Paul Heyman, just to try to remind people to hate him. But the thing is, we love Paul Heyman. Sure, he’s a smarmy heel, and you hate his character…but Paul Heyman the man is no mere mortal when it comes to wrestling. Cesaro needs a shot in the arm, and more importantly, WWE Creative needs a shot in the arm to realize how to properly utilize him. 

The Intercontinental Championship Feud 

Alright, here’s the deal: I really like Dolph Ziggler. The guy should be main eventing by now. He’s got the moves, he can sell an opponent’s offense like no one else (Seth Rollins is the only other guy that can remotely sell like Ziggler), and he has the attitude. But, for some reason, WWE would rather keep him mired in the midcard while guys like Roman Reigns, who are bigger but have less personality, climb to the top. I also like the Miz. There, I said. I like the Miz. I like his character. He does exactly what you want a heel to do. He makes you hate him. 

Once Ziggler and the Miz began feuding, their feud reached comedic proportions, but it was keep the fans’ attention. Miz brought in Damien Sandow (now Mizdow) as his stunt double. Ziggler countered by bringing in R-Truth as “R-Ziggler.” 

At Night of Champions, Miz defeated Ziggler for the title, grabbing the tights when he rolled Ziggler up. On Raw the next night, Ziggler reclaimed the title, using Miz’s own tricks against him. An argument could be made that trading the title back and forth so much cheapens it, but I don’t really agree. It shows that the feud is fairly evenly matched. If given the opportunity, I would eventually have Miz win the feud, maybe at Hell in a Cell. Afterwards, Miz starts calling out wrestlers that we know are not in the building, and then bragging about how no one will face him. Meanwhile, he keeps belittling Damien Sandow. Finally, Sandow snaps and blasts Miz with the title, setting them up for a feud and getting Sandow to be a babyface for the first time. 

If you don’t know, Damien Sandow is fantastic on the mic. For some reason, WWE thought it would be a good idea to let him win the World Heavyweight Championship MITB briefcase in 2013. When John Cena returned from injury and defeated Alberto Del Rio for the title, Sandow confronted Cena the next night on Raw. He beat Cena with the briefcase and then cashed in. For whatever reason, though, Creative could not get past the idea that Cena has to win every time, and so a one-armed John Cena defeated a fully healthy Damien Sandow. This sent Sandow into a character tailspin. Of course, Creative’s reliance on John Cena has sent many characters into a tailspin. 

The Curious Absence of Bray Wyatt 

Case in point, Bray Wyatt. The feud Wyatt and Cena carried into WrestleMania was actually quite good. Everyone around will tell you that Wyatt should’ve won, but again, WWE thinks John Cena should only ever win. Cena and Wyatt faced off at Extreme Rules and it took Wyatt, Harper, Rowan, and a child with laryngitis to defeat Cena. At Payback, Cena and Wyatt engaged in a Last Man Standing match that saw John Cena literally bury Bray Wyatt. 

Wyatt was thrown into the Money in the Bank ladder match, but did not figure in the decision. He then attacked Chris Jericho, leading to a series of matches, one at Battleground, one at SummerSlam, and finally a cage match on Raw. Wyatt won the feud, but once again WWE Creative booked him to look as weak as possible. 

I wrote to a friend the other day that it seems as though the Creative team called Wyatt into the office and said “Alright, here’s what we’re going to do. We’re going to book you against John Cena. You understand that John Cena is the greatest thing to ever happen to me…er, I mean, to the WWE, and so I can’t…I mean, we can’t let you dominate him. Cena’s gonna win at WrestleMania, we’ll let you win at the next pay per view, but we’ll come up with something creepy, like a hoarse childe or something, and then at Payback, well, Cena’s gonna have to bury you…literally. I mean, we’re not having a Buried Alive match, but if we still did, Cena would be dancing on your grave at the end of the night. Then, if you’re still over after our best efforts to destroy you…I mean, build you into a monster heel, we’ll talk about our next step. Now, go wait in the hall and send in my favorite wrestler…err, John Cena.” 

Then, at Night of Champions…no Bray Wyatt. On Raw the next night…no Wyatt Family at all. On SmackDown? Same story. The problem is the WWE have a true monster heel, but they’re so encumbered by their TV-PG rating that he can’t do anything. The heels basically have to be cowards in TV-PG, because the heelish things they did in the Attitude Era are no longer allowed. The television rating is quite literally holding Bray Wyatt down. 

The Tag Team Title Feud 

The Dust Bros. are your new tag team champions. They bested the Usos at Night of Champions. Honestly, the Usos should’ve dropped the titles long ago. WWE had plenty of chances to put the belts on the Wyatt Family and create some new feuds, or on a babyface version of the Dust Bros. But no, they turned the Bros. heel and had them beat down the Usos. 

Now, with the Dust Bros as champions, the potential contenders are: The Usos. Yep, that’s pretty much it. Are you noticing a pattern yet? What I’m trying to drive home is that WWE Creative has failed to properly build their roster. They have plenty of talent, but they try so hard to get the babyfaces over and to make the heels look like cowards that it destroys the credibility of the wrestlers. 

The tag team division should have the Usos, the Dust Bros., the Wyatt Family, the Ascension (currently NXT), Slater Gator (Heath Slater and Titus O’Neil), the Woods Faction (no, I’m not letting that one go), and the World’s Strongest (oldest) Tag Team. Instead, expect another few months of Usos vs. Dust Bros. Why build up someone new when you can keep going back to the same match week after week? More on that later. 

The Seth Rollins Saga 

Former Shield “Architect” Seth Rollins currently holds the MITB briefcase. He was scheduled to face Roman Reigns at Night of Champions, but Reigns was rushed to the hospital Saturday for legitimate emergency surgery. The last I heard, Reigns is out for the next 4-6 weeks. Rollins instead took to the ring and issued basically an open challenge. He was met by the returning Dean Ambrose. 

Seth Rollins trying to kill Dean Ambrose
On Raw, Ambrose opened the show by saying he was there for Rollins and would not leave the ring. He grabbed a chair and sat down. Then we heard the music of Career-Obliterator John Cena. Ambrose smirked at Cena and, in some ways, teased a potential feud. They were met by the Authority, with Seth Rollins hiding behind everyone. Ambrose and Cena attacked and got to Rollins, who ran off. Triple H ordered Kane to face Ambrose (boring, as Kane is past his prime and has slowed considerably in the ring), and Orton to face Cena for about the 150th time this year. 
Obviously, this is leading to Rollins vs Ambrose in a Hell in a Cell match. Now it’s just to see if Creative will see it through, or if they’ll try to saddle us with another lumberjack match. 



Overall Product 

I saw written in another place the statement that part of the reason for the downfall of WCW was their continual (over)reliance on already established wrestlers instead of working to establish new guys. When you look at WCW from 1995 to their final collapse in 2001, you see that the top of their card was Hogan, Flair, Sting, and Savage. Before the end of the Monday Night Wars, WCW would lose a lot of young talent to WWE. Guys like Chris Jericho, Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, and Raven would all jump ship from WCW. 

Well, it’s pretty obvious that WWE is now in that same position. The roster has loads of talent, even if it’s not that deep. 

The main event tier at the moment is John Cena, Brock Lesnar, and Randy Orton. If healthy, Daniel Bryan would be on that list. Roman Reigns is fast approaching that tier. 

The upper midcard, guys that can either main event, if necessary, or play foil on the midcard titles, is made up of Sheamus, Big Show, Mark Henry, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, Bray Wyatt, Dolph Ziggler, the Miz, and Cesaro. 

Everyone else basically slots into lower tier spots on the roster. The problem is, WWE only seems capable of managing one storyline at a time, so a lot of these guys suffer from having characters with no direction and no drive. There are all kinds of things WWE could do to alleviate that problem…it just requires them actually crafting good stories… 

Some Actually (Hopefully Halfway Decent) Story Ideas

1. Have the Intercontinental Champion be guaranteed a WWE World Heavyweight Title Shot at one of the B-Level pay per views. This would enhance the value of the Intercontinental Championship and would create some interesting story lines. Imagine if Randy Orton was WWE World Heavyweight Champion and Seth Rollins was the Intercontinental Champion at the time of the appointed pay per view… 

2. So something special for the US Title. Maybe have two guys go Best-of-Seven or have an Iron Man match for it. Do some things that will elevate the prestige of the title. 

3. For the love of all that is holy, stop using Raw and SmackDown as a vehicle to promote Total Divas. 

4. Have more #1 Contender tournaments. Not Battle Royals. Tournaments. 

5. Bring back the King of the Ring, with the winner getting a WWE World Heavyweight Title shot at SummerSlam. 

6. Create a Tag Team Money in the Bank briefcase. 

05 September 2014

Fantasy Booking: Sheamus and the US Title

The mid-card titles of the WWE, the United States Championship and the Intercontinental Championship, and the wrestlers who currently hold them, have been woefully misused over the last few years. Let’s focus on the United States Championship, or US Title, for the time being. 

The current title-holder is Sheamus, who took the belt off Dean Ambrose in what was one of the most poorly executed start-then-suddenly-stop heel turns in recent memory. Sheamus, you see, is a bit stale. His character is basically the same as it was three years ago. WWE sought to shake things up a bit, and so they moved to turn him heel, using the slow burn heel turn. 

Whether or not this slow-burn turn is still in effect is debatable. Sheamus won the title by Brogue Kicking Dean Ambrose during a battle royal for the title. The Irishman tossed Ambrose from the ring and captured the gold. At the time, both wrestlers were babyfaces, though Ambrose was rather newly minted as a babyface. It was the perfect storm. Everyone knows that Sheamus is work-out partners with Triple H, so having him turn heel, and presumably join the Authority at some point, made great sense. 

But instead, WWE halted the heel turn and continued to run same old boring Sheamus out for match after match. Ambrose, meanwhile, drifted away from the US Title and was embroiled in a feud with Seth Rollins before being written out in order to film a movie. 

That leaves us with a stale babyface holding a mid-card title and no real challengers on the horizon. Sure, there’s been a bit of a program with Cesaro, but he’s another character stuck in WWE creative limbo. 

So let’s engage in some fantasy booking… 

Sheamus defeats Cesaro at Night of Champions, retaining the US Title. I personally think this is a given, so it’s not really fantasy. 

The next night on Raw, John Cena, having lost once again to Brock Lesnar, states his case that he’s the only one capable of defending the WWE against the Beast Incarnate. Triple H, tired of Cena’s schtick (aren’t we all?), calls him out. As the Authority surrounds Cena, looking to beat him down, Sheamus, the Big Show, and Mark Henry run down to make the save. Triple H sets up a tag team match featuring Cena and Sheamus against Rollins and Orton. 

As the match draws toward the end chaos ensues, as is typical for Raw, and all four men end up in the ring. Sheamus hits a Brogue Kick…on John Cena. He doesn’t even act like it was a mistake. Instead, he picks up Cena and hits and Irish Curse backbreaker and then White Noise. Sheamus turns to find Triple H standing on the ring apron. They shake hands. 

Violá, Sheamus is a heel and he’s in the Authority. This is automatic new life to the Sheamus character. Think back to his time as a heel when he first came to WWE. It’s that, but with the full backing of the front office. A newly-heel Sheamus can carry a program with Cena until Lesnar returns. He can function as the non-cowardly heel, willing to take on any fighters.

Of course, this is all just a crazy idea that'll likely never come to pass...

19 August 2014

What's Happening in the WWE?

SummerSlam, the second biggest show for the year for WWE, has come and gone. The post-PPV Raw has come and gone. Here’s what we learned:


The Brie Bella – Stephanie McMahon story line just got confusing.
The tag team scene is confusing.
Creative’s weird booking is confusing.
Bray Wyatt is confusing.
Seth Rollins is becoming a great heel.
Brock Lesnar demolished John Cena.

Those are the high points. I’d like to talk about each one, in no particular order. Let’s break it down.

Twin Magic & Heel Turns

Brie Bella challenged Stephanie McMahon to a match prior to SummerSlam. Stephanie carried the workload of the match, which is surprising. She’s not been in the ring in over 10 years, yet she carried Brie Bella through the action. Then the confusion began. Nikki Bella, whom Stephanie McMahon had tortured for weeks, turned on Brie, allowing Stephanie to win.

On Raw, Nikki claimed that she hated being in Brie’s shadow, and so she wanted out. Brie came to the ring to confront her, and Nikki slapped her. Now we have the Bella Twins in a feud. Think about this, Nikki Bella, a third-tier performer in the ring, actually turned heel before her boyfriend (John Cena). The Bella Twins, possibly the worst actors on the roster, have shown more character range than the company’s “golden boy.”

Tag Teams That May or May Not Make Sense

The tag title picture is confusing. The simple truth is that the Wyatt Family should’ve won the tag titles long ago. Luke Harper is one of the best big men in wrestling today. His partner, Erick Rowan, doesn’t have the range of Harper, but he makes up for it with insanity, intensity, and pure strength. He scoop-slammed Big Show with relative ease on Raw. Beyond that, the Wyatts have great chemistry with the Usos.

Instead, WWE has decided to move the Wyatts away from the tag titles. Leaving the belts on the Usos is an okay move, as the Usos are good champions. But it now requires Creative to build up new threats to them. The Dust Bros. (Goldust and Stardust) are not yet being fully pitched as title contenders. The Ascension is still at NXT, though they’re expected to be called up soon. And now we have the team of Big Show and Mark Henry.

Sure, the pairing has revitalized their careers, but truthfully they’re just two aging superstars who don’t belong in the main event scene anymore. Pairing them up as a tag team gives them something to do, provides Creative with a reliable draw, and means fans will always see a well-worked match.

But it could all be better. And it’s all Creative’s fault. Why?

False Starts

For some reason, WWE Creative has gotten into a rhythm of beginning a story line, only to abandon it within a couple weeks. They might give it a little longer, but they’re still going to abandon it.
This could've been really awesome...

About three weeks ago, Kofi Kingston and Big E lost a tag team match. Afterwards, Xavier Woods showed up in a suit a delivered a solid, if cryptic, promo. On Main Event, Big E and Kingston teamed up and displayed a much more vicious side. They were shown back stage watching other matches. They came to ringside to watch matches. And the fans were behind it. It was hailed as the second coming of the Nation of Domination. An all-black stable of mid-carders fed up with their role.

And then it stopped. No explanation. It just stopped. Kofi came to the ring by himself and he was once again happy-go-lucky Kofi Kingston. Big E came to the ring by himself. No one saw Xavier Woods. Sure, at Hulk Hogan’s birthday celebration last week the three were standing on the side of the stage wearing similar colors. But the new stable was dead on arrival. Creative just gave up. And no one knows why.

Sheamus, the stalest character in the history of modern WWE, was supposed to turn heel. Defeating Dean Ambrose in the battle royal for the US Title was supposed to be the start of his heel turn. And we all know Sheamus needs a character re-invention. A heel turn is perfect for him. He was better as a heel, anyway. Instead, Creative halted the heel turn and Sheamus is still the always-smiling FELLA!-shouting guy he was. I’m sure we’ll get another 1-800-FELLA commercial soon.
If this happens again, we riot...

Cesaro was one of the most “over” guys in the company. Fans loved him. He had a move-set that most babyfaces would kill for. His “giant swing” brought everyone to their feet. He was primed for a babyface turn. He won the Andre the Giant Memorial battle royal at WrestleMania 30, lifting and body-slamming the Big Show out of the ring to win.

On the next Raw, as Hulk Hogan presented him the trophy, Cesaro announced that he was leaving Zeb Colter, a solid heel at the time. Fans erupted. Then Cesaro announced he was joining Paul Heyman. Heyman was/is the heel to end all heels. He manages Brock Lesnar, who had just ended the Undertaker’s streak at WrestleMania. But Heyman is good enough to manage a babyface with Cesaro and a heel with Lesnar. But Creative forced Cesaro back into the heel role and it has absolutely halted any momentum the guy had.

His teammate with Zeb Colter, former Wolrd Heavyweight Champion Jack Swagger, has been the victim of so many false start pushes that fans no longer view him as a credible threat to anyone. Even when Swagger and Colter turned babyface to feud with Rusev, Creative refused to allow anyone to go over the monster heel, and so Swagger’s sudden babyface push has been halted. He not only lost at SummerSlam, but Cesaro beat him on the next Raw and Bo Dallas came out and mocked him. Talk about kicking someone when they’re down.

And it’s all Creative’s fault.

The Curious Ordeal of Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt should be a monster top tier heel by now. He should be. Instead, Creative entered him into a feud with John Cena. At WrestleMania, in a match that would’ve served to bring up a new frontline heel, without damaging Cena’s reputation, Cena took the win. The feud wasn’t over, but it was starting to look bleak. At Extreme Rules, Cena faced Wyatt in a cage match. This was supposed to stop outside interference, but Harper and Rowan were involved the whole time. Cena was poised to win this match, when a small child with an oddly distorted voice came out and sang to him. Yes, that happened.
Bray Wyatt...whom Creative is confused about...

Wyatt won the cage match, but his reputation was suffering thanks to Creative refusing to allow Cena to lose cleanly. At Payback a month later, Cena faced Wyatt in a Last Man Standing match. Anyone thinking that WWE would look to establish a future star needed to turn the TV off. John Cena was not losing a feud to Bray Wyatt. Cena won the LMS match by, literally, burying Bray Wyatt. It was a great match, but the outcome proved that WWE wasn’t really serious about a new heel threat to the top of the card.

Wyatt entered the WWE World Heavyweight Championship ladder match at Money in the Bank, but was basically a non-factor. He entered a feud with Chris Jericho that saw Jericho win at Battleground. Wyatt evened the series at SummerSlam, but most of the damage has already been done. So much damage has been done to his momentum that he basically has to start over.

If I told you a guy that, since Royal Rumble, had singles victories over Daniel Bryan, John Cena, and Chris Jericho, and had competed in the MITB ladder match for the WWE WHC, would basically be starting over, you'd have to realize just how bad Creative has screwed up.

Seth Rollins: Heel

Rollins, the man holding the Money in the Bank briefcase, has the full protection of the Authority. How do we know? Because he’s yet to face his nemesis, Dean Ambrose, cleanly. Their first potential match was a bit of bait-and-switch by WWE. The match was advertised, but it was canceled under the pretense that Triple H threw Ambrose out of the building. The two brawled several times that night.
Rollins trying to rip Ambrose's head off...

At SummerSlam, they finally fought. Ambrose had won a “Beat the Clock” challenge to name the stipulation for the match. In their infinite wisdom, WWE Creative decided that the best bet for this feud was a Lumberjack Match. Most fans scoffed at the notion, but once in the ring, Rollins and Ambrose delivered a fantastic show.
Of course, even with the ring surrounded by other wrestlers, the two fought into the crowd, they brawled outside the ring, and they took out several of the lumberjacks. And, of course, Kane interfered in the match, allowing Rollins to win.

At this point, Seth Rollins is one of the most protected stars on the roster. Sure, he recently lost to Heath Slater, but even that was used to further elevate his feud with Ambrose. Rollins and Ambrose once again fought on Raw, and once more Kane interfered, but this time it was more vicious, and it probably means we’ve seen the last of Ambrose for a while.

Dean Ambrose is due to film a movie, which means WWE had to write him off of weekly programming. They probably did this by having Rollins hit Ambrose with the Curb Stomp while Ambrose’s head was lying on a pile of concrete blocks. It was a vicious assault that makes the audience sympathize with Ambrose while realizing that Rollins is now one of the top tier heels on the roster.

Brrrrrrrrrrrock! Lesnar!

John Cena was the WWE World Heavyweight Champion. Was. He was not on Raw. Brock Lesnar gained a shot at the title on Raw a few weeks back. He entered the ring at SummerSlam and basically destroyed John Cena. It was the single most lopsided victory I think I’ve ever seen anyone score over Cena.

Former enemies, now (apparently) friends
It’s rare that John Cena puts over anyone cleanly. Actually, to be more accurate, it’s rare that Creative allows someone to go over John Cena cleanly. The fact that Lesnar not only went over clean, but truly demolished Cena speaks volumes. What it says, though, is confusing. Is the Cena era over? If so, why replace Cena with a part-timer who is the same age?

We now have a WWE World Heavyweight Champion that is only contracted to work a few days per year. It will be up to Paul Heyman to build any feud Lesnar is in. But who challenges him? Sure, John Cena will get a rematch, probably at Night of Champions in September. But it’s unlikely Cena regains the title. That would cheapen Lesnar’s build. After ending the Undertaker’s streak at WrestleMania, the only thing left for Lesnar was to challenge for the title. Destroying Cena the way he did further builds the myth of Brock Lesnar.

WWE is in the process of building Roman Reigns into a main event challenger, but I don’t think Reigns will actually main event a pay-per-view until WrestleMania 31. Daniel Bryan is an option, but he’s still out with an injury. Randy Orton is an option, but most fans are as tired of him being in the main event picture as they are with Cena.

We'll see where this goes. Rumor is that WWE is already discussing Brock Lesnar's role in WrestleMania 31. According to this rumor, Triple H is pushing for Roman Reigns to take on Lesnar. Vince McMahon, however, wants Lesnar to face The Rock. While that will draw in the casual viewers, having Rock vs Brock as a main event of WrestleMania will do nothing for the future of the industry. Reigns may be ready for a main event by then. Right now, he simply isn't.

09 June 2014

Anatomy of a Heel Turn

In March I wrote an article examining the fine art of a “babyface turn.” That article, in particular, dealt with the Shield turning from the heel stable they'd debuted as, to the babyface stable that would stand against the Wyatt Family and the Authority. Of course, all good things have to end...

In wrestling, for every good guy there has to be a bad guy. For every babyface turn somewhere down the line there is a heel turn. Last Monday, The Shield, as we'd always known them, ceased to be. Seth Rollins delivered the finishing blow; siding with Authority leader Triple H and Evolution.

Heel turns are, arguably, more important that babyface turns. Most people will give you the benefit of the doubt. It’s not common to dislike or hate someone the very first time you see them, unless they deliver a bad first impression. A heel turn, then, must give the audience reason to “boo” a wrestler. To do so, in this day and age of “smarks” and the IWC, requires an action so despicable that those who cheered you on can no longer bring themselves to do it.

Let’s examine a few of the more notable heel turns to see how things were done:

The Third Man

In the late 1990s wrestling fans bore witness to the famed “Monday Night Wars,” as WWF/WWE and WCW battled for ratings supremacy. Wrestlers jumped from one promotion to the other. Cutthroat tactics became the order of the day. That is, until WCW landed what might’ve been the deathblow to WWF, had the booking gone better.
In May 1996, Scott Hall (formerly WWF’s Razor Ramon) showed up on Monday Nitro. Shortly thereafter, Hall’s friend Kevin Nash (formerly WWF’s Diesel), made his debut on Nitro. The two quickly took on the team name of “The Outsiders.” The appearance of Hall and Nash resulted in a lawsuit by WWF, claiming WCW was using WWF characters; intellectual property. The case went nowhere.

Hall and Nash terrorized WCW for a while, and then began claiming that the “third member” of their party would soon be joining them. At Bash at the Beach 1996 (7 July 1996), Hall and Nash met the team of Sting, Lex Luger, and Randy Savage. The Outsiders repeatedly said that the “third man” was in the building.

The match was a brawl. Sting landed a Stinger Splash on Kevin Nash, but Luger was trapped in the corner behind him, and the move hurt Luger worse than Nash. Luger was taken to the back, evening the numbers game. The fight wore on…

Hall and Nash took control of the match up until the moment that perennial good guy Hulk Hogan ambled to ring side (I use that term appropriately. This was the first clue that Hogan was the “third man,” seeing has he merely trotted down to the ring). Hall and Nash abandoned the ring, leaving Hogan staring them down and a prone Randy Savage lying on the mat behind him. Referee Nick Patrick gave Hogan an incredulous look and held up three fingers in question. Hogan pushed him out of the way and delivered a monster leg drop to Savage.

In the aftermath, as “Mean” Gene Okerlund got in the ring to interview the trio, fans littered the ring and the ring side area with trash. Hogan gave a sterling, though scathing, promo insulting the fans and pointing out himself and the Outsiders as the “new world order of professional wrestling.” The moniker stuck, though it was obviously nowhere near has spontaneous as the naming of the Four Horsemen.

This was a textbook heel turn. Hogan would later express regret over having been a babyface for so long. It was now time for him to look out for himself. Gone was Hulkamania and the Hulkster. In was Hollywood Hogan. He changed his attire from the red and yellow he’d worn for years to a black and white motif that matched the nWo.

This turn also revitalized wrestling, giving WCW an undisputed lead in the Monday Night Wars. But, as I said earlier, the booking failed. Initially, the nWo was one of the best things to happen to pro wrestling in years. But because of WCW’s structure, in which several of the big-name wrestlers had incredible creative control over their characters, the entire company began to flounder. In an effort to save things, WCW brought in Vince Russo.

WCW was eventually purchased by Vince McMahon, but the failure of WCW is not the fault of Hulk Hogan turning heel.

Stone Cold is Shaking Hands with the Devil himself

Ask any WWE fan to list the greatest WrestleMania events in history and each one of them (most likely) will have WrestleMania 17 (or WrestleMania X-7) very high on that list. It remains my all time favorite installment of WWE’s marquee show.
The build-up to WrestleMania 17 was great, as everyone prepared for the Rock vs Stone Cold Steve Austin for the WWF Championship. It wasn’t often that the WWF gave fans a babyface vs babyface main event at WrestleMania. It also happened to be the top two superstars of the day. The Rock carried the WWF Championship into Houston for the event. Austin won a title shot by winning the 2001 Royal Rumble.

The match became a “No Disqualification” match, thanks to a last minute announcement. As with Hogan’s entrance, this was a clue very few picked up on at the time. The match was back and forth, with both men kicking out of each other’s finishing moves. During the excitement, an exhausted Vince McMahon, fresh off a Street Fight loss to his son, Shane, made his way to ring side.

McMahon pulled the Rock away from a pin-fall opportunity. The distraction allowed Austin to hit a Rock Bottom on his opponent. After another Stunner, the Rock was still able to kick out at two. This led an angered Vince to hand Austin a chair. Sixteen chair shots later, Austin and McMahon, longtime rivals, were celebrating together in the ring. This was a shocker. No one expected Austin to turn heel (even though he’d always been a tweener), much less to see Austin align with McMahon.

The next night on Raw, things went from bad to worse for the rest of the roster. In a steel cage rematch, Austin took on the Rock. Triple H rushed to the ring, seemingly to take out his old nemesis, Austin. However, The Game proceeded to lay out the Rock with a sledgehammer. The rock was subsequently written out of programming as part of a suspension angle. Austin and Triple H stormed ahead as the newly renamed “Two-Man Power Trip.”

Triple H would completely tear his quadriceps muscle a few weeks later, causing him to miss the entirety of the Invasion angle, as the newly purchased WCW was folded into the WWF. Some people consider that fortuitous, seeing as the booking really failed the company during that angle.

But on April 1, 1002, fans nationwide were left struggling for and answer as to why Austin did what he did. As Jim Ross proclaimed from ringside that night “Stone Cold is shaking hands with the Devil himself!”

The Beginning of the Slow-Burn Turn of CM Punk

A slow-burn heel turn is one in which a wrestler doesn't go fully heel. He'll drift into tweener territory for a while, letting individual actions build up a profile of a truly dastardly heel.

Enter CM Punk.

Punk was WWE Champion entering the special 1000th episode of Raw. On that same episode, the returning, and very much part-time wrestler, the Rock, announced that he had been granted a WWE Championship match at the 2013 Royal Rumble. Punk was also in line to defend the WWE Championship against John Cena, who was cashing in the Money in the Bank contract he'd won just two weeks earlier.

Punk's match with Cena wore on until the Big Show interfered. Show knocked out Cena and Punk reluctantly covered the fallen challenger. Cena, in typical Cena fashion, kicked out. Children everywhere squealed with glee.

Punk tried to land a GTS on Cena, but Cena countered and caught Punk in the STF submission hold. Big Show once again interfered, causing a disqualification and leaving the title on Punk. Show continued his assault on Cena as Punk walked away. Ever the consummate actor, Punk displayed reluctance and regret over leaving. Until the Rock came running in to make the save. Rock knocked Big Show to the ground and was about to deliver the People's Elbow when CM Punk returned and clotheslined Rock. As the Rock lay on the mat writhing from the attack, Punk picked him up and delivered an staggering GTS, leaving Rock knocked out.

This would be the start of a fairly slow burn heel turn, in which CM Punk still got solid fan reaction and support, but every day saw him drift closer to full heel territory, culminating in him joining forces with Paul Heyman and roping in the Shield to do his dirty work.

CM Punk is one of those wrestler that can work well as a heel or a babyface. Personally, I enjoy his heel work better, as it gives him more freedom than being a babyface allows.

There’s Always a “Plan B”

Another shocker of a heel turn took place just last Monday night, when Seth Rollins threw in his lot with Triple H and Evolution, leaving The Shield crumpled in the ring after a series of vicious chair shots.

But a heel turn takes more than just one wrestler turning on another, or turning on the fans...a heel turn takes reactions from all parties. Dean Ambrose delivered the perfect reaction to the Rollins turn. Reigns wasn't really able to react, as he was the first one taken out.

While Triple H and Randy Orton stood a ringside, Rollins did what no one else had been able to effectively do: He took out the Shield. Sure, the Wyatt Family had beaten the shield before, but no one had ever taken them out the way Rollins did. It was a classic heel turn. No one saw it coming. And it just might elevate everyone's careers.

And let's face it, that's what a good heel turn, or babyface turn, should do. Everyone involved should come out better on the other side...so long as John Cena's not involved (but that's another story for another day).